Episode 5 of Agatha All Along raises the stakes as it brings unexpected character revelations and emotional depth, all while balancing the quirky humor and horror elements that have defined the show so far. Though not without its flaws, this episode manages to provide viewers with enough intrigue and excitement to keep them invested as the season heads toward its conclusion. The narrative continues to surprise, offering more insights into Agatha’s dark past while teasing larger MCU connections, especially regarding Billy Maximoff. Overall, fans who enjoy the show’s unique blend of camp and drama will find plenty to appreciate here.
Spoilers Ahead:
Episode 5, titled “Darkest Hour / Wake Thy Power,” takes a major turn by unveiling the true identity of Teen, revealing him to be none other than Billy Maximoff, Wanda’s son. This twist, though widely speculated, is executed in a way that still delivers a satisfying punch. The moment when Teen’s powers manifest, showing blue energy and a crown similar to Scarlet Witch’s, sets the stage for his darker role moving forward.
The episode also dives deeper into Agatha’s backstory, particularly her strained relationship with her mother, Evanora Harkness. Evanora’s possession of Agatha provides chilling moments, especially when she claims that Agatha was “born evil” and should have been killed at birth. This adds a layer of tragedy to Agatha’s character, making her motivations more understandable while still maintaining her antagonistic role.
We also get to see more of the Salem Seven, who have been reimagined as the offspring of the witches Agatha murdered when she destroyed her original coven. Their creepy, hive-minded behavior adds a horror element that contrasts well with the campier parts of the episode. However, the episode does feel a bit rushed at times, particularly in its handling of side characters like Rio Vidal. Aubrey Plaza’s portrayal of Rio, switching between comedic and sinister, continues to be a highlight, but her character’s development remains inconsistent.
The trial scene, where Agatha faces judgment for her past actions, delivers some of the episode’s most intense moments. The confrontation between Teen and Agatha, where Teen questions the morality of becoming a witch, is especially gripping. The emotional tension culminates with Teen’s decision to turn on Agatha, ultimately tossing her into a pit alongside Jen and Lilia. It’s a fitting cliffhanger, setting up the next episode for more dramatic confrontations.
While some fans may find the predictability of certain plot points underwhelming, the way the show plays with audience expectations—especially through Lilia’s clairvoyance and the ongoing mystery of whether certain events are real or premonitions—keeps things engaging. The episode balances these narrative complexities with lighter moments, though at times the tonal shifts can be jarring.
Looking ahead, the fallout from this episode promises to reshape the dynamics of the series, as Billy’s rise to power could make him a central villain, paving the way for Agatha’s potential redemption or deeper descent into villainy. Despite some pacing issues, Episode 5 of Agatha All Along manages to blend Marvel-esque action with its trademark campiness, all while leaving audiences eager to see how the story unfolds.